JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.
Vieraskieliset / In-english

Blog: Re­a­son or emo­ti­ons

Vieraskieliset / In-english
22.7.2019 6.02

Juttua muokattu:

23.12. 02:44

”Pe­op­le have a per­va­si­ve il­lu­si­on that they make their de­ci­si­ons ra­ti­o­nal­ly, alt­hough their li­ves are of­ten do­mi­na­ted by emo­ti­ons”, says a well-known Fin­nish brain spe­ci­a­list Lau­ri Num­men­maa.

He quo­tes Jo­nat­han Haidt, an Ame­ri­can psyc­ho­lo­gist. Ac­cor­ding to Haidt, re­a­son and emo­ti­ons are like an elep­hant and its ri­der. The ri­der, rep­re­sen­ting re­a­son, ima­gi­nes that the elep­hant, or the emo­ti­ons, will go whe­re­ver the ri­der wants. But in ac­tu­al fact, the elep­hant will go exact­ly where it wants, and the ri­der can on­ly hang on and stay on the ride. The prob­lem is made more se­ve­re by the fact that the elep­hant and the ri­der do not speak the same lan­gu­a­ge.

”This is a known fact in ad­ver­ti­sing and po­li­tics. It is much ea­sier to inf­lu­en­ce pe­op­le by ap­pe­a­ling to their emo­ti­ons than their re­a­son.“ Num­men­maa quo­tes the con­fu­si­on about child­hood vac­ci­na­ti­ons as a good examp­le. The count­less stu­dies that have shown vac­ci­na­ti­ons to be safe are not enough to con­vin­ce wor­ried pa­rents, when an on­li­ne ru­mor about a sing­le child get­ting sick be­cau­se of vac­ci­na­ti­on goes vi­ral. Emo­ti­ons beat re­a­son ten to zero.

Ac­cor­ding to Num­men­maa, the ba­sic emo­ti­ons – an­ger, hap­pi­ness, fear, dis­gust, sad­ness and surp­ri­se – are ba­sed on bi­o­lo­gi­cal pre­dis­po­si­ti­ons com­mon to all pe­op­le. Re­gard­less of their cul­tu­re, pe­op­le feel dis­gust at see­ing blood or a pu­ru­lent wound, are af­raid of the dark, and feel more sad­ness or hap­pi­ness for those dear to them than for comp­le­te stran­gers. ”It is as­to­nis­hing how lit­t­le we can mo­di­fy these ba­sic emo­ti­ons. When a per­son at­tends pi­a­no clas­ses for a ye­ar, he or she le­arns to play the pi­a­no. But if a per­son has de­ve­lo­ped a pho­bia or an­xie­ty, it is very hard to un­le­arn it.”

How do re­a­son and emo­ti­ons af­fect faith? I have of­ten been as­ked how I can be­lie­ve the way I do when there are so many dif­fe­rent kinds of faith. Our re­a­son fo­cu­ses on facts. Is there proof that one faith is the cor­rect one? Chris­ti­ans say that we have God’s word and his­to­ri­cal in­for­ma­ti­on about Je­sus’ life. But no mat­ter how much in­for­ma­ti­on we have, it can­not arou­se faith is us.

Apost­le Paul wri­tes that we can­not know God by our own wis­dom, ”For sin­ce, in the wis­dom of God, the world did not know God through wis­dom, it ple­a­sed God through the fol­ly of what we pre­ach to save those who be­lie­ve”(1 Cor. 1:21).

Mar­tin Lut­her, in his exp­la­na­ti­on of the third ar­tic­le of the Creed, says, ”I be­lie­ve that I can­not by my own re­a­son or strength be­lie­ve in Je­sus Christ, my Lord, or come to Him; but the Holy Ghost has cal­led me by the Gos­pel.”

When Apost­le Paul pre­ac­hed the gos­pel in Phi­lip­pi, there was a God-fe­a­ring wo­man cal­led Ly­dia among his lis­te­ners. ”The Lord ope­ned her he­art to pay at­ten­ti­on to what was said by Paul.” (Acts 16:14). Faith is comp­le­te­ly a work of God and a gift of God. He gi­ves us the strength and en­ligh­tens our un­ders­tan­ding to comp­re­hend the mys­te­ries of God’s king­dom. ”By faith we un­ders­tand…” (Heb.11:3).

Yet know­led­ge and in­for­ma­ti­on do play a role in re­li­gi­on. When Chris­ti­ans do mis­si­on work, they exp­lain to their lis­te­ners what is me­ant by God’s king­dom and sal­va­ti­on pre­pa­red by God. In ot­her words, they give ra­ti­o­nal­ly comp­re­hen­sib­le in­for­ma­ti­on to pe­op­le who have ne­ver he­ard about sal­va­ti­on. When we te­ach our child­ren about faith at home, in Day Circ­le, Sun­day School or Con­fir­ma­ti­on Class, we give them in­for­ma­ti­on about these mat­ters. Yet, faith is not me­re­ly know­led­ge, re­a­so­ning or in­sight.

Some pe­op­le feel that their per­so­nal in­ter­nal ex­pe­rien­ces and fee­lings have led them to faith. They base their re­la­ti­ons­hip with God on their emo­ti­ons. We may hear them say, “My God is not so strict about this.”

Re­li­gi­ous mo­ve­ments com­mon­ly ap­pe­al to emo­ti­ons. I ex­pe­rien­ced this per­so­nal­ly when I se­arc­hed for God’s king­dom. Some pra­yer mee­tings were high­ly char­ged emo­ti­o­nal­ly: many pe­op­le pra­yed aloud and down­right pres­su­red one to make a de­ci­si­on. Some said, “Lis­ten to yo­ur in­ter­nal voi­ce and fol­low its ad­vi­ce.”

Li­ving by one’s emo­ti­ons is like being on a rol­ler co­as­ter ride for great ex­pe­rien­ces. It is cer­tain­ly true that God can grant a be­lie­ver warm fee­lings of grace. They rise from faith when God’s grace warms the sin­ner’s he­art. God al­lows such fee­lings ac­cor­ding to his will. They do not give rise to faith, nor are they ne­ces­sa­ry signs of faith.

Both re­a­son and emo­ti­ons give us poor ad­vi­ce con­cer­ning faith. Faith is a gift of God gran­ted and main­tai­ned by God through His Holy Spi­rit. God en­ligh­tens us through His Spi­rit and gi­ves us the ne­ces­sa­ry un­ders­tan­ding for tem­po­ral mat­ters. He al­so gi­ves us gra­ti­tu­de, con­tent­ment and hap­pi­ness along with our faith as well as joy and love of ot­her pe­op­le. Be­lie­vers can se­cu­re­ly trust in God’s gui­dan­ce in their life.

Text: Ola­vi Val­li­vaa­ra

Trans­la­ti­on: Sirk­ka-Lii­sa Lei­no­nen

You will find the ori­gi­nal Fin­nish blog post here.


Kun To­tuu­den Hen­ki tu­lee, hän joh­taa tei­dät tun­te­maan koko to­tuu­den. Joh. 16:13

Viikon kysymys